25 Best Italian Family Style Restaurants In NYC

Are you looking for the best Italian family-style restaurants in NYC? Look no further!
From Carbone to Bamonte’s, we’ve rounded up 25 of the top spots for authentic Italian food. Whether you’re in search of classic dishes like pizza and pasta or something a little more unique, these places have it all.
With recipes passed down through generations, each restaurant brings something special to the table.
Let’s take a tour of the best Italian family-style restaurants in New York City and find out why they’re considered some of the best in town.
Carbone
You’ll feel like you’re part of the family when you dine at Carbone, an Italian eatery that serves up classic family-style dishes with a modern twist.
This Little Italy hotspot is one of New York City’s best Italian restaurants. Its tomato sauce has been praised by the New York Times for its homemade pasta.
Located on Mulberry Street in the West Village, Carbone’s dining room has earned it a Michelin star. It has become a great spot to enjoy classic Italian dishes in the United States.
With housemade pasta, olive oil from Staten Island, and a wine bar fit for any gathering, Carbone is truly the epitome of a family-style restaurant.
Not only that, but co-owner Rita Sodi was named one of Times Square’s Best Restaurants for her handmade pastas!
Whether you’re looking for an upscale Italian experience or just need a great place to eat dinner with friends, Carbone is sure to satisfy your craving for delicious homemade pasta.
Capizzi
At Capizzi, you can experience a cozy atmosphere reminiscent of an Italian home-style dinner. This NYC gem is known for its good food, combining traditional Italian flavors with modern culinary techniques. It’s the perfect choice if you’re craving some delicious Italian-American restaurant fare.
Here, you can enjoy some of the best Italian food in town, like their signature dishes – the best pasta and New York-style pizza. The portions are generous and sure to leave everyone feeling satisfied!
Plus, it’s nestled in the heart of Il Cortile; one of the city’s most vibrant neighborhoods. Diners can take in all that this area has to offer while savoring Chef Rich Torrisi’s creations.
With Capizzi as your choice for a family-style meal, it’ll be hard to beat Carmines Italian Restaurant or Tony’s Di Napoli or La Mela!
La Lanterna di Vittorio
Experience true Italian hospitality at La Lanterna di Vittorio, an inviting eatery in New York City. Located on the Lower East Side and Sheepshead Bay, this family-style spot is one of the best places to find fresh pasta in NYC.
With an extensive menu that caters to picky eaters, it’s no wonder why it’s known as one of the top Italian spots around town. Not only does La Lanterna di Vittorio offer classic dishes like their famous lasagna, but they also boast an impressive wine list and homemade ice cream for dessert.
Whether you’re on the Upper West Side or in Brooklyn, you won’t be disappointed by this inviting restaurant with its family-friendly atmosphere and delicious cuisine.
Peppino’s Brick Oven Pizza & Restaurant
Head over to Peppino’s Brick Oven Pizza & Restaurant for a delectable slice of pizza. The eatery is renowned for its traditional Italian cuisine from Southern Italy, with a modern take on classic dishes. It has something for everyone, be it bone marrow or pork chops accompanied by white wine.
Along with pizza, you can also enjoy fried dough and other seasonal dishes. All the ingredients are sourced from Arthur Avenue in the Bronx to bring authenticity to every dish.
Enjoy an unforgettable Italian meal here with your family!
Keywords Used: New Jersey, Fried Dough, Seasonal Dishes, Bone Marrow, Southern Italy, Traditional Italian Cuisine, Arthur Avenue, Pork Chops, White Wine
Bullet List:
- Delicious pizzas made from fresh ingredients sourced from Arthur Avenue in the Bronx
- Classic dishes from Southern Italy given a modern twist
- A range of options including bone marrow and pork chops paired with white wine
La Mela Ristorante
Come to La Mela Ristorante for a taste of true Italian-American cuisine. This East Village staple has been serving New Yorkers since the 1980s, and serves up some of the freshest ingredients around.
From classic pasta dishes to family-style pizzas, there’s something for everyone here. Whether you’re looking for a night out with your loved ones or a casual evening with friends, La Mela offers an amazing tasting menu that won’t disappoint.
The must-try dish is their authentic Italian pizza – made with the freshest ingredients and cooked in traditional brick ovens. So come on down and experience some of the best pizza NYC has to offer! It’s sure to be an unforgettable family trip!
Don Antonio
Stop by Don Antonio for a taste of the freshest, most delicious Neapolitan-style pizza around! This popular Italian restaurant is located on the Upper East Side and Long Island, offering affordable prices for the highest quality ingredients.
Here’s what you’ll get when you dine at Don Antonio:
- Delicious food: Enjoy classics like broccoli rabe and more.
- Great service: Relax in an atmosphere with white tablecloths and attentive staff.
- Special menus: Try something new every visit with rotating specials.
Experience why Don Antonio is one of NYC’s best Italian family-style restaurants—delicious food, great service, and special menus make it a must-try!
Lombardi’s
Experience the original taste of New York-style pizza at Lombardi’s—the first pizzeria in America! This classic spot has been a favorite place for family dinners since 1905 and still serves up delicious Italian-American cuisine with a modern twist.
Tra di noi, or ‘among us’, is the motto at Lombardi’s, where they’ve updated their menu but kept its traditional spirit. The theater district spot also features flatscreen TVs that air sports, making it a great place to catch the game while sampling Nonna Dora’s famous pies.
Come to Lombardi’s and experience why this is one of NYC’s best Italian family style restaurants.
Cucina & Co.
Treat yourself to the contemporary Italian flavors of Cucina & Co. and savor a taste of the Mediterranean! Located in Brooklyn among brick walls, this cozy Italian restaurant is the perfect place for small groups looking to indulge in an amazing Italian meal.
With an entire gluten-free menu, it’s no wonder why Cucina & Co is one of NYC’s top Italian restaurants. Try their signature cacio e pepe dish, a hearty meal sure to please even the pickiest eater. Or try one of Angie Rito’s specialties—you won’t be disappointed!
Visit Cucina & Co for a better place to enjoy a traditional Italian meal with friends and family!
Da Nico Ristorante
Savor the authentic flavors of Southern Italy at Da Nico Ristorante, an intimate spot offering a truly unforgettable culinary experience.
Serving up classic Italian dishes in a warm and inviting atmosphere, this family-style eatery has been delighting diners for over 20 years.
Expect to find:
- Freshly made pasta dishes
- A variety of delicious seafood specials
- An extensive wine list to pair with each meal
- Homemade desserts that will tantalize the taste buds.
Photo credit goes to the hardworking staff who provide excellent service despite long waits during peak hours. But trust us, it’s worth it!
Da Nico Ristorante is sure to make your next Italian dining experience one you won’t forget.
Trattoria Trecolori
Continuing our exploration of the best Italian family style restaurants in NYC, Trattoria Trecolori is a restaurant that should not be missed.
You’ll find it tucked away in the heart of Greenwich Village and you won’t regret making the trek there. The cozy atmosphere – complete with white-clothed tables and dim lighting – sets the tone for an unforgettable experience.
The menu features classic Italian dishes prepared to perfection, all made with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. A highlight is their signature Neapolitan pizza, cooked in a wood-fired oven and served up bubbly and delicious. Even better? Prices are reasonable so you can enjoy multiple courses without breaking the bank!
Whether you’re looking for an intimate date spot or a place to take your entire family out for dinner, Trattoria Trecolori is sure to please.
Umberto’s Clam House
Head to Umberto’s Clam House in Little Italy for an unforgettable evening of Italian dining. This iconic restaurant has been around since the 1970s and is well known for its delicious seafood dishes.
If you’re looking for a truly authentic Italian experience, this is the place to be. The ambiance is warm and inviting with cozy booths and white tablecloths. You’ll be welcomed by friendly waitstaff who can help you navigate their extensive menu – from lobster ravioli to linguine with clams, there’s something for everyone.
Finish off your meal with one of their house-made desserts like tiramisu or cannoli. Prepare to be amazed by this delightful Italian eatery!
Il Mulino New York
Experience true Italian cuisine at Il Mulino New York. Located in the heart of Greenwich Village, this family-style restaurant serves up authentic Tuscan-inspired dishes. From homemade pastas to veal and seafood entrees, the menu offers a wide variety of options.
The atmosphere at Il Mulino is warm and inviting. The open kitchen and soft lighting create a cozy setting for a romantic dinner or a casual night out with friends.
The menu features classic Italian favorites as well as innovative takes on traditional recipes. With attentive service and delicious food, it’s no wonder why this restaurant has been around since 1981.
Treat yourself to a memorable dining experience at Il Mulino New York today!
La Masseria
Treat yourself to an unforgettable Italian experience at La Masseria! Located in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, this restaurant is a renowned destination for authentic cuisine and warm hospitality. From the charming decor to the delicious dishes, you’ll be delighted by every aspect of your visit.
Enjoy:
- Handcrafted pizzas cooked in traditional brick ovens
- Fresh homemade pasta made daily from local ingredients
- Seasonal menu with innovative dishes that delight all five senses
- An extensive wine list featuring premium Italian labels
No matter what you order, each bite will take you on a journey to Italy’s finest culinary traditions! With its vibrant atmosphere and attentive service, La Masseria offers an exceptional dining experience that will leave you wanting more.
Patsy’s Italian Restaurant
Embark on a delicious culinary adventure at Patsy’s Italian Restaurant! This iconic restaurant first opened in 1933 and has since become a staple of NYC dining.
It’s known for its family-style Italian dishes, including homemade pasta, veal parmigiana, and the classic Chicken Alfredo. The menu is filled with traditional recipes that have been passed down from generation to generation.
To ensure the highest quality, all ingredients are always fresh and locally sourced. The atmosphere is cozy yet elegant, making it perfect for special occasions or romantic dinners.
Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or an unforgettable meal, Patsy’s Italian Restaurant promises to deliver an unforgettable experience!
Rao’s
Step into Rao’s and be transported back in time to a classic Italian eatery, where the warmth of tradition meets the vibrancy of modern dining. You’ll find:
- Authentic cuisine prepared using only fresh ingredients
- A warm and inviting atmosphere with dedicated service
- Private rooms for an intimate dining experience
This legendary restaurant has been satisfying locals since 1896 with its classic Italian fare that never disappoints. From their signature marinara sauce – loved by many celebrities – to the handmade pasta dishes, Rao’s is a must-visit destination for foodies looking for authentic Italian family-style cuisine.
With its close proximity to Little Italy, it’s no wonder that this restaurant has remained a favorite for over 120 years.
Rocco’s
Experience the flavors of Italy at Rocco’s, where classic Italian cuisine is served with a modern twist. From lasagna to veal parmigiana, every dish reflects the heart and soul of Italian cooking.
The welcoming staff will make you feel like family from the moment you walk in the door. Enjoy an array of delicious homemade dishes in a rustic atmosphere that captures the essence of Southern Italy.
Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner or an evening out with friends, Rocco’s is sure to delight all your senses! With its authentic cuisine and warm ambience, this restaurant is sure to become one of your favorites.
John’s of 12th Street
Treat yourself to an unforgettable dining experience at John’s of 12th Street. Here, traditional Italian dishes are served with a modern flair. From handmade pastas to wood-fired pizzas, this family-style restaurant offers something for everyone.
-
An extensive wine list featuring carefully curated selections from the old world and new.
-
A cozy atmosphere that encourages conversation and laughter.
-
Creative cocktails crafted with local ingredients.
-
And, of course, a warm welcome from the friendly staff.
Enjoy a memorable meal with your closest friends and family at John’s of 12th Street!
Il Gattopardo Ristorante
Indulge in an unforgettable dining experience at Il Gattopardo Ristorante. Classic Italian dishes are served with a modern twist, offering incredible flavors and aromas. Chef Vito Gnazzo expertly crafts each dish on the menu. The succulent veal scallops and signature lobster ravioli are just a few examples of the culinary delights you can expect. The freshest ingredients are sourced from all over Italy to ensure the highest quality.
Not only will you enjoy a delicious meal, but you’ll also find a wide selection of unique wines to complement your dining experience. The extensive wine list offers something for every palate.
Il Gattopardo provides a cozy atmosphere and attentive service, making you feel right at home. The restaurant offers a truly luxurious experience that is sure to impress.
Come and discover why Il Gattopardo is one of NYC’s most beloved Italian eateries. This family-owned restaurant has earned a reputation for its exceptional cuisine and warm hospitality.
Da Gennaro
If you’re looking for an authentic Italian family-style restaurant in NYC, Da Gennaro should be at the top of your list. With a cozy atmosphere and food crafted to perfection with fresh ingredients, it’s sure to please all palates.
The menu features classic dishes like lasagna Bolognese, chicken parmigiana, and spaghetti carbonara. For those who prefer seafood-based dishes, try the mussels zuppa or grilled octopus salad.
And don’t forget about their delicious homemade tiramisu for dessert! Whether you’re sharing a meal with friends or treating yourself to an intimate dinner date, Da Gennaro is guaranteed to make your experience one you won’t forget.
San Marzano
Head over to San Marzano for a delicious Italian meal that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds! Located in the heart of NYC, this cozy family-style restaurant has been serving traditional Italian cuisine since 1999.
From traditional favorites like lasagna and spaghetti with meatballs, to more inventive dishes like ravioli stuffed with ricotta and spinach, you won’t be disappointed.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for a dinner out with friends or family. Don’t forget to try the house specialty – tiramisu made from scratch each day!
With generous portions and friendly service, it’s no wonder San Marzano is one of NYC’s favorite Italian restaurants.
Graziella’s
Embark on an unforgettable culinary journey at Graziella’s for a unique Italian dining experience! Located in the heart of New York City, Graziella’s is a family-style Italian restaurant renowned for its authentic cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere.
Featuring a menu with classic dishes such as lasagna, spaghetti with meatballs, and eggplant parmigiana, Graziella’s offers something for everyone. The homemade ingredients used to prepare each dish are sure to tantalize your taste buds and leave you wanting more.
What sets Graziella’s apart from other Italian restaurants is the care that goes into every meal – from hand-selected ingredients to careful preparation techniques. This attention to detail ensures that each bite is full of flavor and delight.
Enjoy a truly one-of-a-kind experience at Graziella’s!
Bamonte’s
If you’re looking for an old-school Italian dining experience, then Bamonte’s is the place to go. This family-style restaurant has been serving authentic Italian cuisine in Brooklyn since 1900. It’s a true testament to the timelessness of great food and atmosphere.
Here are some of the reasons why you’ll love dining at Bamonte’s:
-
Quality:
-
All ingredients are fresh and locally sourced whenever possible.
-
Dishes are cooked with skillful technique and attention to detail.
-
Traditional recipes have been passed down through generations of owners.
-
Atmosphere:
-
The décor is classic yet modern – featuring original wood paneling, checkered floor tiles, and white tablecloths.
-
There’s a warm neighborhood vibe that makes it feel like home – from the friendly staff to loyal regulars who come back again and again.
-
Live music on select nights adds an extra layer of charm to the evening.
-
Value:
-
Prices stay low without sacrificing quality or service – making it accessible to locals and tourists alike!
Carmine’s Italian Restaurant
Carmine’s Italian Restaurant is a must-visit spot for anyone looking for an unforgettable dining experience. Founded in 1990, this restaurant has become a staple of New York City’s Italian family-style dining scene.
Serving up classic dishes like lasagna and veal Parmesan, the restaurant is renowned for its generous portions and delicious homestyle cooking.
The atmosphere is cozy and warm, perfect for large groups or intimate dinners. The servers are friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, making sure you get exactly what you want.
Carmine’s is also known for its great wine list – choose from a selection of carefully chosen wines to pair with your meal!
Whether you’re celebrating something special or just catching up with friends over dinner, Carmine’s Italian Restaurant will make it an occasion to remember!
Pisticci
Head to Pisticci for an amazing Italian dining experience!
Get ready for four courses full of delectable dishes like:
- Spaghetti al pomodoro classici, a hearty pasta dish made with San Marzano tomatoes and basil;
- Involtini di melanzane, eggplant rolls filled with ricotta cheese and herbs;
- A generous helping of polpette al sugo, meatballs simmered in tomato sauce;
- Finally, a classic Tiramisu for dessert, a must-have at any Italian dinner table.
Enjoy the warm atmosphere and attentive service as you indulge in delicious authentic cuisine that will transport you to Italy right here in NYC.
Whether you’re planning a romantic evening out or celebrating with family and friends, Pisticci is sure to satisfy all your Italian food cravings!
Osteria Morini
For a truly luxurious Italian dining experience, Osteria Morini is the place to go. Located in SoHo, New York City, this modern-day trattoria features delicious dishes from the Emilia-Romagna region of Italy.
Guests can enjoy traditional cuisine from pasta and polenta to wood-fired pizzas and oven-roasted meats. The atmosphere is cozy yet refined with its warm colors and rustic decor.
The menu offers something for everyone, whether it’s small plates or large family style feasts. The restaurant also boasts an extensive wine list featuring both classic Italian wines as well as popular new world varietals.
The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about all their offerings which only adds to the overall experience. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner for two or a family gathering, Osteria Morini will provide an unforgettable culinary adventure!
Conclusion
You’ve just read about 25 of the best Italian family-style restaurants in NYC. From the classic Carbone to the family-style Carmine’s, you can be sure that there is something delightful for everyone.
Whether it’s a romantic dinner at La Lanterna di Vittorio or a pizza night at Peppino’s Brick Oven Pizza & Restaurant, these restaurants will provide an unforgettable experience that will leave you wanting more.
So what are you waiting for? Grab your friends and family and explore some of these amazing Italian eateries!