45+ Best Pizza in Times Square NYC

top pizza spots times square

Pondering about the plethora of pizza places in the pulsating heart of New York City, Times Square? You're not alone. It's a daunting task to determine where to dine, given the multitude of mouth-watering options.

From family-owned establishments serving up slices steeped in tradition, to trendy new joints pushing the culinary boundaries of this classic comfort food, Times Square has it all.

As we embark on this saucy journey together, you'll discover over 45 pizza places that stand out in the crowd, and maybe, just maybe, find your next favorite slice.

But here's a question to whet your appetite: what makes a pizza place truly unforgettable? Let's find out.

John's Pizzeria: Broadway Authenticity

authentic pizza on broadway

If you're seeking a slice of authentic New York style pizza in the heart of Times Square, then John's Pizzeria is a must-visit.

Not just any pizzeria, John's of Times Square, offers what many claim to be the best pizza in Times Square. It's not just the thin crust and the perfect ratio of cheese to sauce that wins patrons over, it's also the historic ambiance.

You see, this pizzeria is housed in a former church, providing a unique backdrop to your NYC adventure. Grab a slice before a Broadway show, and you'll quickly understand why it's a local favorite.

The bustling atmosphere, the rich flavors, the echoes of Broadway – that's the freedom you yearn for, and that's what John's Pizzeria delivers.

Angelo's Pizza: 57th Street Classic

delicious pizza on 57th street

While John's Pizzeria offers a taste of Broadway, just a few blocks north on 57th street, you'll find another NYC gem, Angelo's Pizza, a classic haunt that's been serving slices to hungry New Yorkers for decades.

  1. Classic New York: Angelo's Pizza is your go-to if you're craving a classic New York slice. Their thin crust, perfectly charred, with just the right ratio of sauce to cheese, embodies the best pizza in NYC.
  2. Pizza in Times Square NYC: It's often bustling, mirroring the vibrancy of Times Square. You'll feel the pulse of the city here.
  3. Freedom of Choice: You're free to choose from their extensive menu, but the margherita is a crowd favorite.
  4. Experience: This pizza place isn't just about the food; it's about the New York experience. It's a slice of NYC history you wouldn't want to miss.

Patzeria Perfect Pizza: Hidden Gem

delicious pizza in manhattan

Tucked away from the glaring lights and bustling crowds of Times Square, you'll discover Patzeria Perfect Pizza, an unassuming spot that's a true hidden gem in the city's vibrant pizza scene. As a pizza lover, you'll appreciate this pizza restaurant's dedication to crafting the best pizza in Times Square NYC.

Their New York-style pizza, with its crispy crust and robust tomato sauce, is a beautiful representation of pizza in NYC. Each slice is a testament to the skill and passion that goes into perfecting a classic.

While other establishments may compete for attention, Patzeria Perfect Pizza quietly excels, providing a retreat from the city's chaos. Your quest for the best pizza might start and end here, a testament to this hidden gem's undeniable charm.

Luigi's Pizzeria: Times Square Staple

iconic pizza in nyc

Just a stone's throw away from the heart of Times Square, you'll find Luigi's Pizzeria, a much-loved staple that has been serving up slices of heaven for years. This is where you get the best pizza in Times Square.

As a discerning New Yorker who values freedom, here's a list of ways to maximize your Luigi's experience:

  1. Indulge in the classic Margherita slice for an authentic taste of Italy.
  2. If you're feeling adventurous, try Luigi's unique specialty pies.
  3. Choose dine-in for the full Luigi's Pizzeria ambiance.
  4. Don't forget to order a cannoli for the perfect finish to your pizza feast.

With each bite, you'll understand why Luigi's Pizzeria is a Times Square tradition. Bask in the ultimate pizza freedom – you've earned it!

Bella Vita Pizzeria: Italian Craftsmanship

authentic italian pizzas and pastas

Beyond the neon lights of Times Square, Bella Vita Pizzeria showcases the finest of Italian craftsmanship in their mouthwatering pies. You'll taste the authenticity as you bite into the crust, a perfect balance of crunch and chewiness. It's more than just pizza in Times Square NYC; it's an Italian journey in the heart of New York City.

The ingredients tell a story of Italian tradition, each slice a testament to Bella Vita's commitment to preserving the essence of Italian pizza. The mozzarella is creamy and slightly salty, the tomato sauce tangy and aromatic. You're not just visiting one of the pizza places in Times Square, you're stepping into a slice of Italy.

Bella Vita Pizzeria, a gem among New York City pizza joints, offers you not just a meal, but an experience.

Don Antonio: Neapolitan Masterpiece

intricate pizza artistry showcased

While Bella Vita offers a taste of Italy, stepping into Don Antonio immerses you in the heart of Naples, with pizzas that are nothing short of a Neapolitan masterpiece. Here, at this Italian restaurant nestled in Times Square, pizza in New York gets a deliciously authentic upgrade.

To appreciate Don Antonio, consider a four-step approach:

  1. Savor the Crust: Neapolitan pizza is defined by its soft, chewy crust – a true sign of expert craftsmanship.
  2. Relish the Simplicity: The best pizza in Times Square NYC doesn't need fancy toppings. A simple Margherita here is perfection.
  3. Celebrate the Freshness: Every ingredient, from mozzarella to tomatoes, is fresh and vibrant.
  4. Embrace the Ambiance: Remember, Times Square is home to more than bright lights. It's also home to a slice of Naples.

Lazzara's Pizza Cafe: Thin-Crust Perfection

lazzara s pizza perfect thin crust

If you're on the hunt for the perfect thin-crust pizza in Times Square, look no further than Lazzara's Pizza Cafe. This gem stands out among the best pizza places in NYC, its thin-crust perfection being the talk of the town.

Lazzara's isn't just about pizza; it's a celebration of New York-style slices in all their glory. They've mastered the perfect pizza, balancing a delectably thin crust with a robust sauce and the right amount of cheese. The result? A slice that's both rich in flavor yet light enough to enjoy without feeling overwhelmed.

Truly, Lazzara's Pizza Cafe serves the best pizza in Times Square NYC. Don't just take our word for it, visit Lazzara's and experience the thin-crust perfection for yourself.

B Side Pizza and Wine Bar: Gourmet Creations

gourmet pizza and wine

Moving on from the traditional thin-crust delight of Lazzara's, you'd surely be intrigued by the gourmet creations at B Side Pizza and Wine Bar. As one of the best pizza restaurants in Times Square NYC, B Side offers a unique twist to the New York pizza scene.

The gourmet creations are the real showstopper here. You'll find adventurous toppings like truffle honey and pickled jalapeños.

Their wine selection is top-notch, offering the perfect pairing for your pizza.

The ambience, with dim lights and rustic interiors, adds to the dining experience.

Customer service is impeccable, ensuring you're well taken care of.

B Side Pizza and Wine Bar isn't just a restaurant, it's an experience that takes pizza to a whole new gourmet level.

Sacco Pizza: Hell's Kitchen Favourite

iconic hell s kitchen pizzeria

Stepping away from the gourmet scene, you'll find a slice of heaven in the heart of Hell's Kitchen at Sacco Pizza, a local favorite that has been serving mouth-watering pies for decades.

This pizza parlor's charm lies in its simplicity, a refreshing divergence from the city's often overcomplicated endeavors. It's a beacon of authenticity in the city, serving classic New York style city pizza that doesn't try to be anything else.

At Sacco Pizza, the focus is solely on creating the best pizza in Times Square NYC. Thin, crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese create a balance of flavors that's hard to beat.

It's an understated gem in Hell's Kitchen, a testament to the enduring appeal of a simple, well-made pizza.

Capizzi: Rustic Italian Experience

rustic italian cuisine in capizzi

Often overlooked in the hustle and bustle of Times Square, Capizzi offers a genuinely rustic Italian experience with its authentic and hearty pizza pies.

Here's why it's one of the best pizza places in NYC:

  1. Authenticity: Capizzi's menu mirrors the traditional flavors of Italy, transporting you straight to a quaint Italian town.
  2. Quality: Using only the freshest ingredients, each slice of pizza offers a burst of flavor that's unparalleled.
  3. Ambience: The pizzeria's intimate setting, reminiscent of a neighborhood pizza joint in Italy, provides a welcome respite from the city's chaos.
  4. Location: Nestled in the heart of Times Square, Capizzi is perfect for those seeking the best pizza in New York City amidst their sightseeing.

Bravo Pizza: Iconic NYC Slice

classic nyc pizza slice

While Capizzi offers an authentic Italian haven amidst the city's commotion, Bravo Pizza stands out as an iconic slice of NYC, capturing the classic New York pizza experience like no other. You'll find the best slices in Times Square at this bustling spot.

The pizza by the slice is an homage to tradition – thin, crisp, and generously topped. The sauce is tangy, the cheese is perfectly melted, and the crust is just the right amount of chewy. It's everything you'd want in an iconic NYC slice.

Bravo Pizza is undeniably the best pizza in Times Square NYC. With each bite, you're tasting a slice of New York pizza history. For the true freedom seekers, the unapologetically New York approach of Bravo Pizza is a must-try.

Gino's Pizzeria: Family Traditions

gino s pizzeria generational family recipes

Nestled in the heart of Times Square, you'll find Gino's Pizzeria, a family-run institution that's been serving up some of the city's best traditional pizza for generations. This pizza joint is a beacon of the New York-style pizza scene.

Here's a quick guide to maximize your Gino's Pizzeria experience:

  1. Order the cheese pizza, a classic that showcases Gino's mastery of the perfect balance of sauce and cheese.
  2. Savor every bite. The crust, crisp yet yielding, is a testament to years of perfecting the craft.
  3. Don't overlook the ambiance. The family traditions resonate in the warm, inviting atmosphere.
  4. Take home a slice of pizza. You'll want to revisit the best pizza in New York, even after you've left the premises.

Gino's Pizzeria, an embodiment of family traditions and pizza excellence, awaits you.

Little Italy Pizza: Budget-Friendly Options

affordable pizza in little italy

For those seeking a fantastic pizza experience that's easy on the wallet, your next stop should be Little Italy Pizza. As one of the best pizza in Times Square NYC, Little Italy offers budget-friendly options without compromising quality.

Their regular pizza, a fan favorite, is a testament to their commitment to serving great pizza. It's a simple yet delicious pie, with a perfect balance between the crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese.

You'll appreciate the freedom of enjoying a scrumptious meal without breaking the bank, and you'll quickly understand why it's celebrated among the best places for pizza in the city.

Little Italy Pizza is proof that you don't need to spend a lot to enjoy a slice of NYC's finest pizza.

Majestic Pizza: Worth the Hype

delicious pizza worth trying

On your quest for the best pizza in Times Square, you can't overlook Majestic Pizza, a spot that's certainly lived up to its hype. Now, you're probably wondering, 'Is Majestic Pizza worth the hype?' The answer is a resounding yes.

Here's why:

  1. Location: Majestic Pizza is a short walk from Times Square, making it an accessible spot when looking for the best pizza.
  2. Taste: Many claim it's the best pizza in the area, with perfect New York thin-crust style that pizza purists adore.
  3. Service: The staff at Majestic Pizza are friendly and efficient, enhancing the whole experience.
  4. Value: The prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality.

Famous Amadeus Pizza: Late-Night Cravings

late night pizza cravings satisfied

Ever found yourself wandering the streets of Times Square late at night, your stomach growling, craving for a slice of delectable pizza? Don't fret, because Famous Amadeus Pizza is your go-to pizza spot for those late-night cravings.

This is one of the best pizza places in Times Square NYC, that ensures your taste buds are never left unsatisfied. Famous Amadeus Pizza, with its tempting toppings and perfect crust, stands tall among New York's best pizzerias. Whether it's the succulent pepperoni or the traditional margherita, each slice is a symphony of flavors.

This spot is for the free spirits who crave supreme taste and quality, even in the early hours. So, next time you're in Times Square, make sure Famous Amadeus Pizza is on your list.

Conclusion

So, you've explored the top pizza spots in Times Square, NYC. From Broadway's authentic John's Pizzeria to the hidden gem of Patzeria Perfect Pizza, every slice tells a story.

Whether it's Bella Vita's Italian craftsmanship or Gino's family traditions, there's a pizza for every palate.

Don't forget Little Italy's budget-friendly options or Majestic Pizza's much-hyped slices.

And for those late-night cravings, Famous Amadeus Pizza has got you covered.

Truly, Times Square offers a pizza paradise unlike any other.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *