As you start planning your holiday celebrations, you're probably wondering where to book that special Christmas dinner in New York City. With so many options to choose from, it can be overwhelming. But don't worry, we've got you covered. From retro Italian fare to farm-to-table feasts, and from elegant atmospheres to cozy spots, we've curated a list of the 25 best places for Christmas dinner in the city. You might be surprised by some of the hidden gems that made the cut – and we can't wait to share them with you.

Carbone's Retro Italian Christmas

At Carbone, the retro Italian-American restaurant in Greenwich Village, Christmas dinner is a scene straight out of a 1950s holiday movie.

You'll be enveloped in Carbone's nostalgia, surrounded by red leather booths, vintage decor, and a lively atmosphere that'll transport you back in time.

Carbone's ambiance is pure old-school glamour, making it the perfect spot to indulge in a festive feast.

Rolf's German Christmas Spectacle

Every winter, Rolf's German Restaurant transforms into a winter wonderland, a dazzling spectacle that will leave you awestruck.

You'll feel like you're in the heart of Bavaria, surrounded by festive decorations and German traditions.

Enjoy signature dishes like schnitzel and sauerbraten, paired with unique cocktails and cozy vibes perfect for family gatherings.

Loring Place Farm-to-Table Feast

You're trading in Rolf's festive Bavarian vibes for a taste of the countryside at Loring Place, where farm-to-table takes center stage.

Savor seasonal ingredients sourced from local partnerships and farm collaborations, showcased through culinary creativity.

The festive atmosphere is infused with community engagement and eco-friendly practices, making this Christmas dinner a guilt-free indulgence.

The NoMad's Elegant Holiday Meal

Step into the majestic world of The NoMad, where opulence and refinement reign supreme, and Christmas dinner becomes an unforgettable affair.

You'll savor a bespoke holiday menu, replete with unique flavors, amidst a festive atmosphere and elegant service.

Upscale ambiance, seasonal decor, and gourmet choices create a cozy setting, blending culinary traditions with modern flair, making for a truly regal dining experience.

Peter Luger Steak House Classics

As the holiday season unfolds, Peter Luger Steak House beckons with its timeless classics, transporting you to a world of rich flavors and nostalgic charm.

You'll savor Luger's signature Steakhouse traditions, indulging in prime cuts of classic steak.

Make holiday reservations early to guarantee a spot in this festive atmosphere
Enjoy legendary service that elevates your dining experience
Savor the culinary excellence that has given Peter Luger its timeless appeal

Balthazar's French-Inspired Delights

Inside Balthazar, the SoHo institution, a warm, golden glow envelops you, instantly transporting you to the City of Light.

You'll be surrounded by Balthazar's ambiance, complete with festive decorations that set the tone for a magical Christmas dinner.

Savor Balthazar's classic dishes, paired with exceptional wine selections, and indulge in seasonal pastries and decadent dessert menu treats during their special holiday service and festive brunch offerings.

The Dead Rabbit's Irish Holiday Cheer

You'll feel like you're celebrating Christmas in Dublin at The Dead Rabbit, where festive cocktail pairings, like the "Sleigh All Day" and "Rudolph's Red Nose," are expertly crafted to complement their Irish-inspired feast menu.

Savor dishes like roasted goose, corned beef, and colcannon, all infused with a touch of holiday magic. As you indulge in this merry meal, you'll be surrounded by the pub's ornate decorations and lively atmosphere, making it a truly unforgettable Christmas dinner experience.

Holiday Cocktail Pairings

Sipping on a festive cocktail is an integral part of the holiday experience, and The Dead Rabbit's Irish Holiday Cheer is a masterclass in merry-making.

You'll feel the holiday spirit with their expertly crafted cocktail pairings, blending festive flavors and mixology magic.

Savor their signature cocktails, like the Spiced Apple Cider or the Gingerbread Old Fashioned
Warm up with winter warmers like the Hot Buttered Rum or the Tom and Jerry
Toast the season with celebratory drinks that capture the essence of yuletide libations

Irish-Inspired Feast Menu

Joyous anticipation builds as you behold the Irish-Inspired Feast Menu, where The Dead Rabbit's culinary wizards weave a tapestry of traditional Irish flavors with modern twists, crafting a festive culinary experience that will leave you merry and bright.

You'll savor hearty dishes infused with seasonal ingredients, inspired by Irish traditions and family recipes, amidst the cozy pub's festive gatherings, traditional music, and holiday spirits.

Marea's Seafood Extravaganza

Marea's Seafood Extravaganza transforms Christmas dinner into an unforgettable underwater odyssey.

You'll be treated to an exquisite festive atmosphere, complete with sparkling decorations and impeccable service.

Indulge in expertly crafted seafood pairings, like lobster and foie gras or scallops and truffles.
Savor every bite of their decadent seafood tower, featuring oysters, shrimp, and lobster.
Toast to the holiday season with a glass of champagne or a festive cocktail.

Carbone's Over-the-Top Christmas

At Carbone, the retro Italian-American restaurant, you'll be transported to a bygone era of glamour and excess, where Christmas dinner is a lavish, over-the-top affair.

Amidst Carbone's opulent decor, you'll indulge in exclusive holiday specials, like truffle-stuffed turkey, served family-style, paired with expertly curated wine pairings.

Expect festive atmosphere, celebrity sightings, and traditions that'll make you feel like a VIP.

The Lambs Club's Upscale Celebration

Elegance permeates every corner of The Lambs Club, where the stately atmosphere is elevated to new heights during the holiday season.

You'll feel like royalty as you indulge in their upscale dining experience.

Savor their delectable holiday menu, featuring dishes like roasted duck and wild striped bass.
Enjoy craft cocktails in the lavish lounge, surrounded by rich wood and velvet drapes.
Take in the stunning views of the city from the Lambs Club's iconic bar.

The Smith's Seasonal American Favorites

Through the bustling streets of NYC, you'll find a warm and inviting oasis at The Smith, where seasonal American favorites take center stage during the holidays.

As you step inside, The Smith's ambiance envelops you in cozy comfort, setting the tone for a festive feast.

Savor their seasonal dishes, like roasted turkey and sweet potato casserole, crafted with love and care to make your Christmas dinner truly unforgettable.

Ilili's Middle Eastern Holiday Flair

Vibrant colors and enticing aromas transport you to the Middle East at Ilili, where Christmas dinner gets a bold twist.

You'll experience a unique fusion of Middle Eastern spices and festive decorations, blending cultural influences with traditional dishes.

Savor Ilili's signature lamb kofta, infused with warm cinnamon and allspice.
Enjoy the warm, inviting atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings.
Delight in the holiday hospitality, complete with unique flavors and a festive ambiance.

The Russian Tea Room's Classic Festivities

You'll trade in the exotic aromas of Ilili for the opulent grandeur of The Russian Tea Room, where Christmas dinner is a masterclass in old-world sophistication.

Immerse yourself in Russian traditions amidst a festive atmosphere, indulging in classic dishes like Beef Stroganoff and Blini.

Enjoy a tea service with unique beverages, surrounded by stunning holiday decorations, as you experience a cultural phenomenon rooted in dining history.

Gabriel Kreuther's Alsatian Delights

Gabriel Kreuther's eponymous restaurant is a holiday haven, transporting you to the snow-dusted villages of Alsace with its festive Alsatian-inspired Christmas dinner.

You'll be enchanted by:

Traditional recipes infused with seasonal ingredients and regional wines, honoring Alsatian traditions and culinary heritage.
Cozy ambiance reminiscent of holiday markets, perfect for festive gatherings.
Festive pastries and Alsatian hospitality that will make you feel like you're celebrating in the heart of Alsace.

The Capital Grille's Upscale Traditions

At The Capital Grille, the scent of dry-aged steaks and roasting chestnuts fills the air, setting the tone for a sophisticated Christmas dinner that's equal parts refined and indulgent.

You'll feel like you're part of a timeless holiday tradition, surrounded by dark wood, rich fabrics, and impeccable service.

Savor upscale dining at its finest, where every bite is a masterclass in flavor and technique.

Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse

You're in for a treat at Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse, where their Prime Rib Feast is the star of the Christmas show, featuring a slow-roasted prime rib served with horseradish cream and au jus.

As you step into this luxurious steakhouse, you'll be enveloped in an upscale holiday ambiance that's sure to get you in the festive spirit.

With steakhouse twists on classic dishes, you'll discover a fresh take on traditional Christmas fare that will leave you wanting more.

Prime Rib Feast Offerings

Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse takes the reins with its Prime Rib Feast Offerings, a masterclass in opulence that will leave you weak in the knees.

You'll indulge in tender, slow-roasted prime rib, expertly cooked to perfection using time-honored techniques.

Savor festive sides like truffled mashed potatoes and sautéed broccolini, infused with seasonal ingredients.
Pair your meal with expertly curated wine pairings, featuring rich, full-bodied reds.
Complete your dining experience with gourmet sauces, elevating this holiday tradition to new heights.

Upscale Holiday Ambiance Found

Step into Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse and be enveloped by the epitome of upscale holiday ambiance.

You'll be surrounded by luxurious settings, festive decorations, and elegant service that exude a romantic vibe.

This iconic steakhouse honors holiday traditions with seasonal menus, gourmet experiences, and intimate gatherings, creating a celebratory atmosphere perfect for your special night out.

Steakhouse Twists on Classics

Savoring the rich aromas wafting from the kitchen, you'll discover Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse's bold twists on classic steakhouse fare, elevating the holiday dining experience to new heights.

Unique steak preparations, like their signature Double Eagle Steak, boast seasonal flavor profiles that will leave you wanting more.
Savor the tender, slow-roasted prime rib, infused with a hint of horseradish and served with a side of au jus.
Del Frisco's decadent truffle creamed spinach is the perfect side dish to complement your meal.

The Palm's High-End Holiday Dining

You'll feel like a high roller celebrating Christmas at The Palm, where luxurious surroundings and exceptional service set the tone for an unforgettable holiday dinner.

The upscale steakhouse honors holiday traditions with a festive atmosphere, complete with twinkling lights and garlands.

Savor their signature dishes, like prime rib and lobster mac 'n cheese, amidst the elegant décor.

American Cut's Steakhouse Christmas

As you trade The Palm's old-school luxury for a more modern take on the holiday, American Cut's sleek, industrial-chic atmosphere envelops you in a sophisticated Christmas celebration.

You'll find a perfect blend of steakhouse traditions and holiday dining.

Savor dry-aged steaks, expertly prepared to your liking
Indulge in seasonal sides, like truffle mashed potatoes and sautéed broccoli
Toast to the holiday with craft cocktails, featuring festive flavors like cranberry and cinnamon

Ocean Prime's Seafood Holiday Feast

Fresh seafood takes center stage at Ocean Prime's festive holiday feast, where the aroma of succulent lobster and crab wafts through the air, teasing your taste buds and setting the tone for a decadent Christmas dinner.

You'll savor sustainable seafood options, crafted with care to guarantee a guilt-free indulgence.

Festive dining reaches new heights amidst the elegant atmosphere, complete with refined decor and exceptional service.

The Odeon's Classic NYC Holiday

The Odeon's Classic NYC Holiday beckons you to step into a winter wonderland, where the iconic Tribeca restaurant's nostalgic charm is elevated by the magic of the season.

You'll feel the Odeon history in every bite of their classic dishes, served amidst festive decor that embodies New York charm.

Seasonal cocktails crafted to warm your winter spirits
Memorable gatherings in a celebratory vibe that's pure Odeon
A dining experience that wraps you in winter warmth

The Finch's Seasonal American Cuisine

You'll feel like you're celebrating Christmas in a snow-globe at The Finch, where the seasonal American cuisine is as cozy as the atmosphere.

As you scan the menu, you'll spot highlights like roasted beet salad and maple-glazed pork chops, each dish carefully crafted to evoke the magic of the season.

The warm, golden lighting and rustic-chic decor will make you want to linger over your meal, savoring every bite of this winter wonderland.

Seasonal Menu Highlights

Beyond the cozy atmosphere and impeccable service, The Finch's seasonal American cuisine truly shines with its expertly crafted menu highlights, which burst with festive flavors and locally sourced ingredients.

You'll savor the essence of the season in every bite!

Roasted duck breast with cherry compote and wild rice, inspired by traditional holiday flavors
Pan-seared striped bass with winter citrus and herbs, showcasing the best of seasonal ingredients
Decadent chocolate yule log, a gourmet twist on a beloved family gathering classic

Cozy Winter Ambiance

As you step into The Finch, the warm glow of twinkling lights and crackling fireplaces envelops you, instantly putting you in a festive mood.

You're transported to a winter wonderland, surrounded by festive decorations that evoke holiday traditions.

Cozy nooks and warm lighting create intimate gatherings, perfect for savoring seasonal comfort food and festive treats amidst joyful celebrations.

Old Homestead Steakhouse's Holiday Classics

Step into Old Homestead Steakhouse's elegant dining room and let the aroma of roasting meats envelop you, instantly putting you in the holiday spirit.

You'll feel like you're part of a cherished holiday tradition, surrounded by festive recipes that evoke a sense of nostalgia.

Savor their signature filet mignon, served with a rich demiglace
Indulge in their decadent truffle mac and cheese
Treat yourself to a festive holiday dessert, like their eggnog cheesecake

Strip House's Seductive Holiday Dining

As you step into Strip House, you're enveloped in a sultry ambiance that's perfect for a holiday evening, complete with rich red decor and intimate lighting.

You'll be tempted by decadent holiday menu options that put a luxurious spin on seasonal favorites.

Get ready for a seductive dining experience that will leave you feeling merry and bright.

Sultry Ambiance for Holidays

Seduction is always on the menu at Strip House, but during the holidays, the sultry ambiance is amplified, making it the perfect spot for a provocative Christmas dinner.

You'll feel like you're in a luxurious boudoir, surrounded by rich red decor and warm lighting that sets the mood for intimate gatherings.

Velvet drapes and dark wood accents create a sophisticated, old-school vibe
Soft jazz music floats through the air, adding to the seductive atmosphere
The dimly lit dining area is perfect for getting cozy with your loved ones

Decadent Holiday Menu Options

Immerse yourself in Strip House's decadent holiday menu, where indulgent dishes are carefully crafted to match the sultry ambiance.

Savor gourmet appetizers like seared foie gras and truffle deviled eggs, followed by tender filet mignon and pan-seared salmon.

Finish with a luxurious dessert, such as the famous 24K gold leaf cheesecake, making your Christmas dinner truly unforgettable.

Seductive Dining Experience Await

Rich velvet drapes, sultry lighting, and a sophisticated crowd set the tone for a Christmas dinner that's as much about the experience as the exquisite cuisine at Strip House.

You'll be enveloped in a romantic dining experience, surrounded by intimate settings and a festive atmosphere that's perfect for a joyful celebration.

Savor gourmet experiences with sumptuous dishes like filet mignon and seafood towers
Cozy up in elegant decor that's reminiscent of a bygone era
Create new holiday traditions with your loved ones in this sophisticated setting

Bill's Food and Drink's Cozy Christmas

Step into Bill's Food and Drink on Christmas Day, and you'll be enveloped in a warm, inviting atmosphere that's as comforting as a crackling fire on a winter's night.

The holiday decor and festive atmosphere make it the perfect spot for joyful gatherings.

Snuggle into cozy seating and indulge in seasonal specials, comfort food, and classic cocktails, all served up by a cheerful staff.

The Greenhouse Cafe's Holiday Brunch

You'll feel like you're walking into a winter wonderland at The Greenhouse Cafe, where their festive holiday menu options will get you in the spirit with dishes like cranberry orange French toast and eggnog pancakes.

But it's not just the food that's merry – their seasonal cocktail creations, like the "Sleigh All Day" and "Gingerbread Man," are sure to put you on the nice list.

As you sip and savor, you'll be surrounded by a cozy atmosphere that'll make you feel like you're celebrating Christmas morning.

Festive Holiday Menu Options

Savoring the magic of the holiday season is effortless when surrounded by The Greenhouse Cafe's lush greenery and warm ambiance, which sets the tone for a festive holiday brunch that will leave you merry and bright.

You'll indulge in unique dining experiences, savoring traditional holiday flavors with a twist.

Cranberry orange French toast with sweet cream cheese frosting
Herbed crusted beef tenderloin with roasted root vegetables and horseradish cream
Spiced apple cider donuts with caramel dipping sauce

Seasonal Cocktail Creations

As you settle into The Greenhouse Cafe's cozy atmosphere, festive spirits await to complement your holiday feast, expertly crafted to spread cheer and warmth.

You'll find seasonal twists on classic cocktails, like cranberry-infused mimosas and spiced apple ciders, showcasing festive flavors that align with the latest cocktail trends.

Toast to the season with a cup of cheer!

Cozy Atmosphere Ambiance

Step into The Greenhouse Cafe's winter wonderland and surround yourself with the warm, inviting ambiance that defines the holiday season.

You'll feel like you're in a festive fairytale, complete with:

Romantic lighting that sets the mood
Intimate seating areas perfect for snuggling up with loved ones
Festive decorations that transport you to a winter wonderland

Conclusion

You've made it through the list, and now it's time to decide where to spend your holiday cheer. Whether you're in the mood for retro Italian flair, a German winter wonderland, or a classic steakhouse feast, NYC's got you covered. With these 25 outstanding spots, you'll find the perfect blend of atmosphere, cuisine, and festive fun to make your Christmas dinner unforgettable. So go ahead, book that table, and get ready to jingle bell rock your way into a holiday season to remember!