25 Best Bakeries for Thanksgiving Pies and Treats in New York City
When Thanksgiving rolls around, finding the perfect pie or treat can elevate your celebration. New York City’s bakeries offer a delightful variety, from classic pumpkin to innovative mini desserts. Each bakery brings its unique flair, ensuring that your dessert table stands out. Whether you’re hosting a gathering or bringing a sweet surprise, you’ll discover options that cater to every taste. Let’s explore some of the best spots for your holiday indulgence.
Magnolia Bakery
If you’re hunting for the perfect Thanksgiving pie, Magnolia Bakery should be at the top of your list. Known for its delightful treats, their pumpkin pie is a must-try!
While you’re there, don’t skip their famous banana pudding or impressive cupcake selection. Each bite is a reminder of why this bakery remains a New York City favorite during the holiday season.
Baked by Melissa
Baked by Melissa is a delightful gem for those seeking unique Thanksgiving pies in NYC. Known for its mini cupcakes, this bakery offers an array of baked by Melissa flavors that excite the palate.
You can indulge in festive varieties like pumpkin spice and pecan pie, ensuring your holiday dessert table shines with creativity and taste. Don’t miss their adorable cupcake varieties!
Pie Face
Pie Face offers a delightful twist on traditional Thanksgiving pies, making it a must-visit for dessert lovers in NYC.
You’ll discover innovative pie trends that excite the palate, with unique flavor pairings that elevate classic recipes. From rich chocolate pecan to zesty cranberry orange, each bite promises a burst of flavor.
Don’t miss their charming, whimsical presentation—perfect for your holiday gatherings!
Little Pie Company
At Little Pie Company, you’ll find a mouthwatering selection of signature pies that are perfect for Thanksgiving.
With seasonal flavors that change with the harvest, every visit offers something new to savor.
Plus, the cozy atmosphere makes it a delightful spot to enjoy a slice—or two—while you plan your holiday feast.
Signature Pies Selection
When you’re on the hunt for the perfect Thanksgiving pie, Little Pie Company’s signature selection is a must-try.
Their pies boast high-quality signature pie ingredients, like ripe fruits and rich spices, creating unforgettable flavors.
Each pie showcases impressive pie presentation techniques, from flaky crusts to stunning lattice tops, making them not just delicious but also a beautiful centerpiece for your holiday table.
Seasonal Flavors Offered
If you’re craving something special this Thanksgiving, Little Pie Company offers a delightful array of seasonal flavors that will elevate your dessert game.
Indulge in their signature pumpkin pie, infused with rich autumn spices that capture the essence of the season.
Don’t miss their pecan pie, bursting with festive flavors that are sure to bring warmth and joy to your holiday table.
Cozy Atmosphere Experience
There’s something magical about stepping into Little Pie Company, where the warm, inviting atmosphere instantly makes you feel at home.
With cozy seating and inviting decor, you’ll enjoy the comforting aromas wafting through the air. The friendly staff enhances the community feel, while seasonal decorations add a festive spirit.
It’s the perfect spot for intimate gatherings in a relaxed atmosphere, making every visit special.
Milk Bar
At Milk Bar, you’re in for a treat with their signature pie flavors that put a creative twist on classic desserts.
You’ll also find unique offerings that go beyond the usual, making your Thanksgiving selection extra special.
Don’t miss their seasonal specials, which promise to surprise and delight your taste buds this holiday!
Signature Pie Flavors
Milk Bar’s signature pie flavors are a delightful twist on traditional favorites, inviting you to indulge in a unique dessert experience this Thanksgiving.
Embracing holiday pie trends, their offerings feature innovative combinations like the Salty Honey Pie with unique pie ingredients that surprise your palate.
Each bite bursts with flavor, making these pies an unforgettable addition to your holiday celebrations.
Don’t miss out!
Unique Dessert Offerings
Beyond their signature pies, Milk Bar offers an array of unique dessert creations that elevate your Thanksgiving spread.
Immerse yourself in their creative flavor combinations, like cereal milk and birthday cake, which tantalize your taste buds.
With innovative presentation styles, each dessert looks as good as it tastes, making them perfect conversation starters.
Impress your guests with these delightful treats that redefine holiday indulgence!
Seasonal Specials Available
As the holiday season approaches, you’ll find that Milk Bar has rolled out an enticing lineup of seasonal specials designed to elevate your Thanksgiving celebrations. Indulge in delights made with fresh, seasonal ingredients, all adorned with festive decorations to brighten your table.
| Treat | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Cake | Fluffy layers of spiced pumpkin | $45 |
| Apple Pie | Classic, with a buttery crust | $35 |
| Pecan Tart | Rich filling, topped with nuts | $40 |
| Cranberry Cookies | Chewy, with tart cranberry bursts | $25 |
| Sweet Potato Pie | Creamy, with a graham cracker base | $38 |
Flour Bakery
If you’re on the hunt for exceptional Thanksgiving pies in NYC, Flour Bakery should definitely be on your radar.
Founded by renowned pastry chef Joanne Chang, Flour Bakery specializes in mouthwatering desserts like their famous pumpkin pie and apple galette.
With a charming atmosphere and a rich history of baking excellence, you’ll find the perfect treats to elevate your holiday feast.
Amy’s Bread
While you may think of Amy’s Bread primarily for its artisanal loaves and fresh pastries, their Thanksgiving pies are a hidden gem that shouldn’t be overlooked. At various Amy’s Bread locations, you’ll find specialties like pumpkin, pecan, and apple pies, each crafted with care and quality ingredients.
| Pie Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Pumpkin Pie | Creamy, spiced perfection |
| Pecan Pie | Sweet, nutty goodness |
| Apple Pie | Classic with a flaky crust |
| Chocolate Pie | Rich and indulgent flavor |
| Sweet Potato | Unique and festive twist |
Sweet Lady Jane
At Sweet Lady Jane, you’re in for a treat with their seasonal pie offerings that perfectly capture the essence of Thanksgiving.
From their famous pumpkin pie to unique flavor combinations, each bite is a celebration of holiday flavors.
You can easily find a location near you, and their hours make it convenient to pick up your favorites.
Seasonal Pie Offerings
As the leaves turn and the air grows crisp, Sweet Lady Jane welcomes the season with a delightful array of Thanksgiving pies that are sure to impress your holiday guests. With a focus on seasonal ingredients, you’ll find pie variations like pumpkin, pecan, and apple that capture the essence of fall.
| Pie Flavor | Key Ingredients | Seasonal Twist |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin | Pumpkin puree, spices | Maple syrup drizzle |
| Pecan | Pecans, brown sugar | Bourbon infusion |
| Apple | Crisp apples, cinnamon | Caramel topping |
| Sweet Potato | Sweet potatoes, nutmeg | Ginger crust |
| Chocolate Pecan | Dark chocolate, pecans | Sea salt finish |
Signature Treats Overview
Sweet Lady Jane stands out with its signature treats that elevate any holiday gathering.
Their cakes and desserts embrace signature dessert trends, showcasing unique flavor combinations like lemon raspberry and chocolate hazelnut. Each bite is a delightful experience, perfectly balancing sweetness and texture.
Whether you’re craving a classic or something innovative, Sweet Lady Jane’s treats are sure to impress your guests this Thanksgiving.
Store Locations and Hours
Finding the perfect pie for your Thanksgiving feast is easy when you know where to go.
Sweet Lady Jane has multiple store locations across New York City, including the Upper West Side and SoHo.
Their business hours are convenient too, typically open from 10 AM to 8 PM.
Swing by to grab your favorite treats and guarantee a sweet holiday celebration!
Butter & Scotch
At Butter & Scotch, you’ll discover a delightful blend of nostalgia and innovation, making it a must-visit for Thanksgiving pies in NYC.
Indulge in their signature butter flavor that elevates classic recipes, and don’t miss their unique scotch desserts that add a festive twist.
With each bite, you’ll savor memories and celebrate the season in a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Petee’s Pie Company
At Petee’s Pie Company, you’ll discover an array of signature pies that celebrate the essence of Thanksgiving.
Each season brings unique flavor offerings, showcasing fresh, local ingredients that elevate traditional favorites.
With expert baking techniques at play, every slice promises an unforgettable taste experience.
Signature Pie Selections
When it comes to Thanksgiving pies, Petee’s Pie Company stands out with its mouthwatering signature selections that are sure to impress your holiday guests. Their offerings showcase the latest signature pie trends and holiday flavor innovations, ensuring a delightful experience. Here’s a sneak peek at some of their must-try pies:
| Pie Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Classic Apple | Fresh apples, cinnamon, and nutmeg |
| Pumpkin Spice | Creamy pumpkin with warm spices |
| Pecan | Rich, gooey filling with toasted pecans |
| Chocolate Cream | Decadent chocolate custard topped with whipped cream |
| Sweet Potato | Sweet potato blend with a hint of vanilla |
Seasonal Flavor Offerings
If you’re looking to elevate your Thanksgiving feast, Petee’s Pie Company has an array of seasonal flavor offerings that capture the essence of the holiday.
You’ll find pies bursting with seasonal ingredients like pumpkin and cranberry, perfectly paired with spices that evoke warm memories.
Each bite delivers delightful flavor pairings, making your celebration both delicious and memorable.
Don’t miss these seasonal treats!
Baking Techniques and Ingredients
Petee’s Pie Company prides itself on using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients that make each pie a standout. Their baking techniques emphasize precision and care, ensuring every crust is flaky and every filling is bursting with flavor. By focusing on ingredient sourcing, they create delectable treats that celebrate the essence of each season.
| Baking Techniques | Ingredient Sourcing |
|---|---|
| Flaky crusts | Local farms |
| Fresh fruit fillings | Organic suppliers |
| Handmade decorations | Sustainable practices |
| Temperature control | Seasonal selections |
| Wholesome spices | Artisan producers |
Two Little Red Hens
At Two Little Red Hens, you’ll discover a delightful selection of Thanksgiving pies that elevate any holiday feast.
Established in 2000, this charming bakery blends a rich history with a menu of signature desserts, including their famed pumpkin and pecan pies.
Each bite showcases their commitment to quality and tradition, making it a must-visit for your holiday treats in New York City.
Patisserie Tomoko
While exploring the vibrant landscape of New York City’s bakeries, Patisserie Tomoko stands out as a haven for those seeking exquisite Thanksgiving pies. With its warm ambiance and a carefully curated menu, you’ll find delightful options perfect for the holiday. Check out their offerings below that showcase why this patisserie is a must-visit.
| Pie Flavor | Size | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin | 9-inch | $30 |
| Apple | 9-inch | $28 |
| Pecan | 9-inch | $32 |
City Cakes
Just a short stroll from Patisserie Tomoko, City Cakes beckons with its charming storefront and mouthwatering selection of Thanksgiving pies.
Known for its vibrant city cakes flavors, you’ll find everything from classic pumpkin to decadent pecan.
The inviting decor, adorned with whimsical touches, creates a warm atmosphere perfect for enjoying a slice or picking up a whole pie for your holiday table.
Little Cupcake Bakeshop
At Little Cupcake Bakeshop, you’ll find an array of signature pie flavors that are sure to tempt your taste buds this Thanksgiving.
Don’t miss their seasonal specialties that perfectly capture the essence of the holiday, all served in a cozy atmosphere that feels like home.
It’s the ideal spot to savor a slice or two while soaking in the festive spirit.
Signature Pie Flavors
Little Cupcake Bakeshop offers a delightful array of signature pie flavors that are sure to elevate your Thanksgiving feast.
You’ll love their unique flavor combinations, like the spiced pumpkin with a hint of maple or the rich chocolate pecan.
These pies embrace signature pie trends, blending classic tastes with innovative twists, ensuring every bite is a memorable experience for your holiday gathering.
Seasonal Specialties Offered
As Thanksgiving approaches, Little Cupcake Bakeshop takes the opportunity to showcase seasonal specialties that capture the spirit of the holiday.
You’ll delight in their pumpkin spice cupcakes, featuring seasonal ingredients sourced from local farms.
Indulge in festive flavor combinations like cranberry orange and pecan pie bars, perfect for your gathering.
Each treat is crafted to evoke warmth and celebration, making your holiday truly special.
Cozy Atmosphere Experience
Stepping into Little Cupcake Bakeshop feels like entering a warm embrace, especially during the Thanksgiving season.
You’ll love the cozy ambiance, complete with warm decor and inviting seating. The festive lighting combined with comforting aromas creates an irresistible atmosphere.
Enjoy friendly service while surrounded by seasonal decorations that enhance the community vibe.
- Rich pumpkin pies
- Fluffy pecan tarts
- Delightful cupcakes
- Homemade cookies
- Charming holiday treats
The Pie Hole
When it comes to Thanksgiving pies, The Pie Hole stands out as a local favorite, offering a delightful assortment that caters to every palate.
With a flavors variety featuring local ingredients, their unique crust techniques truly shine.
Don’t miss customer favorites like pumpkin and pecan.
Enjoy seasonal promotions, festive packaging, and convenient delivery options.
Plus, consider signing up for their baking classes for a fun experience!
Smorgasburg
Smorgasburg transforms the traditional food market experience into a vibrant celebration of local flavors, and their Thanksgiving pie offerings are no exception.
You’ll discover an array of seasonal treats from talented Smorgasburg vendors, including:
- Pumpkin spice whoopie pies
- Salted caramel apple tarts
- Pecan pie bars
- Maple bourbon cheesecakes
- Sweet potato pie
These delightful options will make your holiday feast unforgettable!
Sarabeth’s Bakery
If you’re seeking the perfect pie to complement your Thanksgiving table, search no more than Sarabeth’s Bakery.
Known for Sarabeth’s specialties like their classic pumpkin pie, each bite bursts with warmth and flavor.
The inviting atmosphere, dotted with charming decor, makes it a delightful stop.
Treat yourself to a slice or two, and experience the holiday spirit infused in every delicious pastry.
Balthazar Bakery
Balthazar Bakery is a crown jewel in NYC’s culinary scene, especially when it comes to Thanksgiving pies.
With a rich history since 1997, this French-inspired haven offers delightful specialties that keep locals coming back.
- Classic pumpkin pie
- Decadent pecan tart
- Flaky apple galette
- Rich chocolate tart
- Seasonal cranberry-orange bread
You won’t want to miss these treats this holiday season!
La Colombe Coffee Roasters
After indulging in the sweet offerings at Balthazar Bakery, make sure to swing by La Colombe Coffee Roasters for a unique Thanksgiving experience.
Known for their exceptional coffee roasting, La Colombe serves rich, aromatic brews that perfectly complement holiday treats.
Grab a cup of their signature blend and enjoy the cozy atmosphere, making it an ideal stop to round out your festive day.
Eileen’s Special Cheesecake
When it comes to finding the perfect Thanksgiving pie in NYC, don’t overlook Eileen’s Special Cheesecake.
This bakery offers a delightful range of cheesecake flavors that’ll satisfy any sweet tooth.
- Classic New York cheesecake
- Pumpkin spice cheesecake for fall
- Decadent chocolate chip cookie dough
- Rich salted caramel topping
- Seasonal fruit toppings like cranberry
You’ll definitely want Eileen’s treats on your holiday table!
Dough
When it comes to Thanksgiving pies, the dough is just as essential as the filling.
You’ll want to understand the different types of dough and how their freshness can make or break your pie’s flavor and texture.
Perfecting that flaky, buttery crust is what turns an ordinary dessert into a holiday masterpiece.
Dough Types Explained
Understanding the different types of dough is essential for crafting the perfect Thanksgiving pie. Each dough type offers unique textures and flavors to enhance your dessert experience.
- Pâte Brisée: A rich, flaky dough.
- Pâte Sucrée: Sweet, cookie-like texture.
- Pâte Feuilletée: Light, layered, and buttery.
- Choux: Airy and puffed, perfect for cream puffs.
- Shortcrust: Tender and crumbly, ideal for savory pies.
Explore these dough types to elevate your baking!
Importance of Freshness
Freshness plays an essential role in the quality of your pie dough, as using ingredients at their peak can considerably enhance flavor and texture.
When you choose fresh ingredients through local sourcing, you not only support nearby farmers but also guarantee your dough is bursting with vibrant tastes.
This commitment to freshness transforms your Thanksgiving pies into unforgettable treats that everyone will savor.
Perfecting the Texture
Achieving the perfect texture in pie dough is an art that requires attention to detail and a bit of practice.
Focus on these key elements for baking consistency and texture balance:
- Use cold ingredients for a flaky crust
- Don’t overmix the dough
- Allow the dough to rest
- Roll it out evenly
- Experiment with different flours
Perfecting these steps will elevate your Thanksgiving pies!
Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream
If you’re looking to elevate your Thanksgiving dessert spread, Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream offers a delightful twist on the traditional pie.
With their unique van Leeuwen flavors, like Pumpkin Cheesecake and Maple Pecan, you’ll savor each creamy scoop.
Their artisan techniques guarantee every batch is crafted with care, making it the perfect complement to your holiday feast.
Enjoy a scoop and delight your guests!
Le Pain Quotidien
When you’re seeking a cozy spot to pick up Thanksgiving pies, Le Pain Quotidien stands out with its artisanal offerings.
Their seasonal menu features delightful treats that’ll elevate your feast. You’ll love:
- Pumpkin spice tarts
- Pecan pies with a flaky crust
- Rich chocolate ganache cakes
- Freshly baked artisanal bread
- Seasonal fruit galettes
Each bite feels like a warm embrace of the holiday spirit!
Sweet Street Desserts
At Sweet Street Desserts, the aroma of freshly baked pies beckons you to indulge in their decadent creations.
Embracing dessert trends and flavor innovations, they use unique ingredients and expert baking techniques. Seasonal offerings, like pumpkin and pecan pies, become customer favorites.
Each treat features creative presentation, inspiring your dessert pairings and elevating your Thanksgiving feast to a new level of deliciousness.
Flour + Water
Flour + Water isn’t just a name; it’s a promise of artisanal excellence in every pie they create.
You’ll savor the delightful blend of seasonal ingredients and artisan techniques that elevate each treat.
- Pumpkin spice pie with homemade crust
- Apple galette featuring local apples
- Pecan pie infused with maple syrup
- Chocolate tart topped with sea salt
- Classic pecan pie with a twist
Conclusion
As you prepare for Thanksgiving, don’t overlook the incredible bakeries of New York City. Whether you crave a classic pumpkin pie, inventive mini cupcakes, or a slice of seasonal fruit pie, these spots have you covered. Each bakery offers a unique twist on festive treats, ensuring your dessert table is a feast for the senses. Treat yourself and your loved ones to these delightful creations, and make your holiday gathering truly unforgettable!
