25 Best New York City Pizzerias You Can’t Miss
If you’re a pizza lover, New York City has an impressive lineup of pizzerias waiting for you. From the historic Lombardi’s to the innovative flavors at Roberta’s, each spot tells its own delicious story. You’ll discover classic slices, artisanal creations, and unique toppings that define the city’s culinary scene. Get ready to explore the vibrant atmosphere and taste the distinctive variations that make these pizzerias unforgettable. Which one will you try first?
Di Fara Pizza
When you step into Di Fara Pizza, you’re entering a legendary slice of New York City history. Founded in 1965, this iconic pizzeria showcases the artistry of its founder, Domenico DeMarco.
Each pie is crafted with fresh ingredients, embodying the essence of pizza history. You can’t help but appreciate the dedication and passion that makes Di Fara a must-visit culinary gem.
Joe’s Pizza
Stepping into Joe’s Pizza feels like grabbing a slice of New York’s vibrant street culture.
With a history dating back to 1975, Joe’s has become a local legend, serving up classic, thin-crust pies.
The atmosphere buzzes with energy, filled with laughter and the tantalizing aroma of fresh pizza.
Here, each slice tells a story, immersing you in the heart of NYC.
Lombardi’s Pizza
Just a short walk from Joe’s Pizza, you’ll find Lombardi’s Pizza, the first pizzeria in the United States, established in 1905.
Immerse yourself in Lombardi’s history with its coal-oven pies, crafted from fresh ingredients. You can’t miss their signature Margherita or the delicious pepperoni.
Each bite transports you through time, making Lombardi’s menu a must-try for any pizza lover visiting New York City.
Prince Street Pizza
When you step into Prince Street Pizza, the aroma of their signature pepperoni slice instantly captivates you.
This unique square pie, with its crispy crust and rich toppings, has become a must-try for locals and tourists alike.
Nestled in the heart of SoHo, this pizzeria offers not just a meal, but a true slice of New York culture.
Signature Pepperoni Slice
If you’re craving a truly iconic slice in New York City, search no more than the Signature Pepperoni Slice at Prince Street Pizza.
This masterpiece features crispy, thick pepperoni slice toppings that are slightly spicy and perfectly balanced.
The signature pepperoni variations create a delightful burst of flavor in every bite, making it a must-try for any pizza lover visiting the city.
Unique Square Pie
The Unique Square Pie at Prince Street Pizza is a game-changer for pizza enthusiasts.
With roots in square pie history, this style features a thick, crispy crust that holds up under generous toppings variations.
You’ll savor each bite of its flavorful sauce and perfectly melted cheese.
It’s a must-try for anyone looking to experience a delicious twist on traditional pizza.
Iconic SoHo Location
Nestled in the heart of SoHo, Prince Street Pizza boasts a vibrant atmosphere that draws locals and tourists alike.
With its iconic pepperoni slices and welcoming Soho ambiance, you’ll quickly understand why it’s a favorite.
Surrounded by historic restaurants, this spot captures the essence of New York City dining.
Don’t miss the chance to savor a slice in this lively neighborhood!
Roberta’s
When you step into Roberta’s, you’re greeted by an eclectic vibe that perfectly complements its mouthwatering signature pizzas.
The wood-fired crusts and fresh, innovative toppings create a culinary experience that’s hard to forget.
Nestled in Bushwick, the atmosphere buzzes with energy, making it a must-visit spot for any pizza lover.
Signature Pizza Offerings
At Roberta’s, each pizza tells a story, combining artisanal craftsmanship with bold flavors that keep you coming back for more.
Their signature toppings, like spicy soppressata and creamy burrata, elevate classic pizza styles to new heights.
Whether you crave a traditional Margherita or a unique white pie, every bite showcases the passion and creativity that define this beloved pizzeria.
Unique Dining Experience
Stepping into Roberta’s feels like entering a vibrant culinary haven, where the air buzzes with the intoxicating aroma of wood-fired pizza and the laughter of friends sharing unforgettable moments.
Here, you’ll commence a culinary adventure that captures the essence of pizza culture. Each visit promises not just a meal, but a delightful experience that lingers long after you’ve left.
Location and Atmosphere
What makes Roberta’s location so enchanting? Nestled in Bushwick, you’ll find a blend of gritty neighborhood charm and vibrant street art.
The outdoor garden, filled with twinkling lights, creates a cozy pizza ambiance that invites you to linger.
Surrounded by the energy of local residents and artists, enjoying a slice here feels like a true slice of New York life.
Totonno’s
Totonno’s, a legendary pizzeria nestled in Coney Island, offers a slice of New York’s rich culinary history.
Founded in 1924, it’s renowned for its coal-fired, thin-crust pies.
You’ll love exploring Totonno’s menu, featuring classics like the Margherita and pepperoni.
Each bite reflects generations of tradition, making your visit a must for any pizza lover seeking authenticity and flavor.
Patsy’s Pizzeria
When you step into Patsy’s Pizzeria, you’re greeted by the aroma of legendary thin-crust pizza, crafted with a family-owned tradition that dates back decades.
Each bite offers a perfect balance of crispy and chewy, making their signature dishes a must-try. You’ll quickly understand why this spot has captured the hearts of pizza lovers across New York City.
Legendary Thin-Crust Pizza
Have you ever tasted a pizza that feels like a work of art?
At Patsy’s Pizzeria, their legendary thin-crust pizza showcases masterful thin crust techniques that create a crisp, delicate base.
Each slice bursts with flavor from legendary toppings like fresh mozzarella, basil, and vibrant tomatoes.
You’ll savor every bite, craving that perfect combination of texture and taste that defines New York pizza excellence.
Family-Owned Tradition
At Patsy’s Pizzeria, the family-owned tradition runs deep, creating an inviting atmosphere that’s as rich as their sauce. You’ll find cherished family recipes passed down through generations, bringing authentic flavors to the table. Their commitment to community support shines through, making every pizza a shared experience.
| Element | Description |
|---|---|
| Family Recipes | Generations of culinary secrets |
| Community Support | Active involvement in local events |
| Atmosphere | Warm and welcoming |
| Ingredients | Fresh, high-quality components |
| Legacy | Over 80 years in business |
Must-Try Signature Dishes
Patsy’s Pizzeria isn’t just about the family-owned tradition; it’s also a haven for pizza lovers seeking unforgettable flavors.
You can’t miss their signature Margherita, featuring fresh basil and mozzarella atop a perfectly charred crust.
Don’t overlook the regional variations, like the spicy pepperoni with signature toppings that elevate each slice.
Every bite showcases the passion and expertise behind this iconic pizzeria.
L&B Spumoni Gardens
While exploring the vibrant world of New York City pizzerias, L&B Spumoni Gardens stands out as a beloved gem in Brooklyn.
With a rich L&B history dating back to 1939, you’ll savor their iconic rectangular slices, perfectly crispy on the bottom.
Don’t forget to indulge in their delicious spumoni flavors, a delightful treat that perfectly complements your pizza experience.
John’s of Bleecker Street
Considered one of the quintessential pizzerias in New York City, John’s of Bleecker Street has been serving up delicious thin-crust pizza since 1929.
Nestled on Bleecker Street, its restaurant ambiance exudes neighborhood charm. You’ll savor local favorites topped with signature ingredients, celebrating pizza history and culinary heritage.
With traditional recipes and various pizza styles, your dining experience here is truly unforgettable.
Motorino
At Motorino, you’ll savor signature Neapolitan pizzas crafted with the freshest ingredients and a perfect blend of flavors.
The cozy atmosphere invites you to relax and enjoy each bite, making it an ideal spot for a casual dinner or a special night out.
With a wood-fired oven at the heart of the kitchen, every pizza emerges with that perfect char and deliciously chewy crust.
Signature Neapolitan Pizzas
When you step into Motorino, the aroma of bubbling mozzarella and fresh basil instantly transports you to the streets of Naples.
Their signature Neapolitan pizzas highlight classic toppings like San Marzano tomatoes and creamy burrata, celebrating pizza history in every bite.
Each pie is crafted with precision, ensuring a perfect balance of flavors that honors the traditions of authentic Italian pizzerias.
Cozy Atmosphere Experience
As you walk into Motorino, the intimate glow of warm lighting and the inviting scent of freshly baked pizza wrap around you like a comforting embrace.
The cozy ambiance invites you to settle in and savor your experience. In these intimate settings, you’ll find:
- Friendly staff
- Rustic decor
- Charming seating
- A welcoming vibe
Every detail enhances your enjoyment, making it a perfect spot for pizza lovers.
Emily
There’s something magical about stepping into Emily, a pizzeria where the aroma of freshly baked dough mingles with the rich scent of melted cheese.
As you explore, don’t miss Emily’s favorites, like the signature Emmy Burger and the crispy, flavorful pizzas.
Each bite reflects Emily’s experiences, combining classic techniques with inventive twists that keep you coming back for more.
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
When you step into Artichoke Basille’s Pizza, you’re in for a treat with their unique flavor combinations that set them apart from the rest.
Don’t miss their signature artichoke slice, a creamy delight that’ll have your taste buds dancing.
With a cozy atmosphere that invites you to linger, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a slice or two.
Unique Flavor Combinations
While many pizzerias stick to traditional toppings, Artichoke Basille’s Pizza boldly embraces unique flavor combinations that tantalize your taste buds.
Their creative toppings invite flavor experimentation, making each slice an adventure. You’ll love trying:
- Spinach artichoke dip
- Crab and cheese
- Vodka sauce
- A spicy twist with jalapeños
Get ready to experience pizza like never before at this iconic spot!
Signature Artichoke Slice
The Signature Artichoke Slice at Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is a must-try for any pizza lover.
With a rich artichoke history, this slice features creamy artichoke toppings that create a decadent flavor explosion. The combination of cheese, spinach, and a hint of garlic elevates this pizza to new heights.
You won’t just eat it; you’ll experience a culinary masterpiece that’s truly unforgettable.
Cozy Atmosphere Experience
Stepping into Artichoke Basille’s Pizza instantly envelops you in a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home.
You’ll love the cozy seating and rustic decor that creates a perfect pizza ambiance.
Enjoy the neighborhood vibe and friendly service while relishing local favorites in intimate dining settings illuminated by warm lighting.
- Cozy seating
- Casual charm
- Inviting atmosphere
- Friendly service
Scarr’s Pizza
Nestled in the Lower East Side, Scarr’s Pizza offers a delightful blend of tradition and innovation that keeps pizza lovers coming back for more.
With a charming ambiance that feels like home, you’ll enjoy every bite of their expertly crafted pies.
Scarr’s toppings are fresh and unique, elevating classic flavors while allowing you to savor the essence of New York pizza.
Bleecker Street Pizza
When you step into Bleecker Street Pizza, you’re greeted by the aroma of fresh, bubbling cheese and perfectly baked crusts.
Their signature slice, topped with a blend of classic ingredients, is a must-try that keeps locals and tourists coming back for more.
Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, the atmosphere buzzes with energy, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a slice of New York’s finest pizza.
Signature Slice Highlights
Bleecker Street Pizza stands out as a quintessential destination for pizza lovers in New York City, renowned for its signature slices that embody the city’s culinary spirit.
You’ll love exploring their unique offerings, which feature:
- Classic pepperoni with a spicy kick
- Fresh mozzarella and basil
- Savory sausage with regional variations
- Seasonal vegetable medleys
Each slice showcases delicious signature toppings options that keep you coming back for more!
Location and Atmosphere
A visit to Bleecker Street Pizza immerses you in the vibrant energy of New York City’s West Village.
The cozy ambiance creates an inviting experience, making it easy to relax while savoring your slice.
The restaurant decor features charming brick walls and vintage accents, enhancing the authentic NYC feel.
You’ll find the perfect blend of comfort and character in this beloved pizzeria.
Best Pizza
How do you define the best pizza in New York City?
It’s a delightful blend of pizza styles and innovative toppings trends. You’ll want to savor:
- Classic New York thin crust
- Chicago deep-dish variations
- Gourmet options with unexpected flavors
- Vegan and gluten-free creations
Each bite tells a story, capturing the city’s vibrant culinary scene.
Immerse yourself and discover your favorite!
Pizza Suprema
Located near Penn Station, Pizza Suprema stands out as a beacon for pizza lovers seeking an authentic New York experience.
Here, you’ll savor slices steeped in pizza history, crafted with a perfect crust and topped with their famous sauce secrets.
Each bite bursts with flavor, showcasing the craftsmanship that’s made this spot a must-visit for anyone craving true New York pizza.
Slice of Life
At Slice of Life, the vibrant atmosphere invites you to take a moment and enjoy pizza in a way that feels both casual and special.
Immerse yourself in New York’s rich pizza culture with local favorites like:
- Classic Margherita
- Spicy Pepperoni
- Veggie Delight
- White Clam
Each bite reflects the heart of the city, making it a must-visit for any pizza lover.
Paulie Gee’s
Paulie Gee’s stands out as a gem among New York City’s pizzerias, enchanting pizza enthusiasts with its artisanal approach and unique flavor combinations.
Nestled in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, its inviting atmosphere complements a diverse menu featuring creative toppings.
With a rich history and glowing reviews, Paulie Gee’s popularity continues to rise, offering a memorable dining experience through its signature pizza styles and unique flavors.
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria reigns as a beloved institution in New York City’s vibrant culinary landscape, famed for its coal-fired brick oven pizzas that boast a perfect char and a crispy crust.
- Rich history dating back to 1905
- Located under the Brooklyn Bridge
- Cozy, inviting ambiance
- Diverse menu featuring classic and specialty pies
You’ll love the attentive customer service that enhances your dining experience!
Joe’s Pizza (West Village)
Nestled in the heart of the West Village, Joe’s Pizza is a quintessential slice of New York City.
With a rich history dating back to 1975, it’s beloved for its classic New York-style pies.
You can’t go wrong with Joe’s toppings, from gooey mozzarella to fresh basil, all perfectly balanced on a crispy crust.
Grab a slice and savor the tradition!
Juliana’s Pizza
Just a short walk from Joe’s Pizza, you’ll find Juliana’s Pizza, a standout in Brooklyn’s DUMBO neighborhood.
With a rich history tied to the legendary Patsy’s, Juliana’s atmosphere buzzes with excitement.
You’ll love the:
- Fresh, artisanal ingredients
- Charred, crispy crusts
- Cozy, inviting space
- Stunning views of Manhattan
Dive into this pizzeria for an unforgettable slice!
Pasquale Jones
Pasquale Jones is a culinary gem located in the vibrant Nolita neighborhood, where the aroma of wood-fired pizza fills the air.
You’ll love the inviting atmosphere, marked by rustic decor and a lively buzz.
The Pasquale Jones menu boasts inventive pies like the clam and garlic pizza, ensuring every bite is a delightful experience.
Don’t miss this must-visit destination!
Pizza Village
Pizza Village stands out as a beloved spot for pizza aficionados in the heart of the Lower East Side.
You’ll love their vibrant pizzeria ambiance and dedication to quality.
Highlights include:
- Fresh local ingredients and unique pizza toppings
- Various slice sizes, including gluten-free crusts
- Tasting events showcasing pizza history
- Convenient delivery options, including vegan choices
You can’t miss it!
Two Boots Pizza
Nestled in various neighborhoods across New York City, Two Boots Pizza offers a unique blend of New York-style and Cajun flavors that’s hard to resist.
You’ll love their creative, unique toppings like shrimp, andouille sausage, and spicy Cajun sauce. Each slice bursts with flavor, making it a perfect spot for adventurous pizza lovers.
Don’t miss out on this delicious experience!
Tali’s Pizzeria
Tali’s Pizzeria is a gem in the bustling streets of New York City, inviting you to indulge in a delightful pizza experience.
With a rich history rooted in traditional recipes, Tali’s offers unique specialties that keep locals coming back.
Don’t miss out on:
- Classic Margherita
- Spicy Pepperoni
- Vegan Delight
- Garlic Knots
Each bite tells a story of passion and flavor!
Conclusion
You can’t go wrong exploring New York City’s pizzerias, each one offering a slice of history and flavor. From the iconic Di Fara to the trendy Roberta’s, every spot invites you to indulge in unique toppings and crust styles. Whether you’re grabbing a classic slice at Joe’s or savoring the artisanal creations at Pasquale Jones, the city’s vibrant pizza scene promises an unforgettable experience. So, grab your friends, and set off on a delicious pizza journey you won’t soon forget!
