35+ Best Pizza Restaurants in Manhattan NYC

top pizza spots in manhattan

Who can resist the allure of a perfectly baked pizza, with its gooey cheese, tangy sauce, and a crust that strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy? You're in luck, because Manhattan is a veritable treasure trove of pizza joints, each with its unique spin on this beloved dish.

We've combed through the city's diverse pizzerias, from age-old establishments serving up traditional slices to trendy spots pushing the boundaries of what a pizza can be. As we reveal the top 35+ pizza restaurants in Manhattan, you'll find yourself on a mouthwatering journey through New York City's pizza scene.

Will your favorite spot make the cut? There's only one way to find out…

Lombardi's Pizza: Little Italy

iconic pizza in nyc

Stepping into Lombardi's Pizza in Little Italy, you're immediately engulfed by the intoxicating aroma of baking dough and bubbling mozzarella, a testament to the century-old establishment's reputation as the first pizzeria in the United States.

Your eyes dart to the coal-fired brick oven, the heart of Lombardi's and creator of what many hail as the best pizza in Manhattan. Each pie, crafted with care, boasts a distinctive smoky flavor and charred crust that can't be replicated.

You feel a sense of freedom in choosing your toppings, a testament to Manhattan's melting pot ethos. It's not just pizza, it's a legacy served on a platter.

Lombardi's isn't merely a pizzeria in Little Italy; it's a cornerstone of Manhattan's culinary history.

Grimaldi's: DUMBO Classic

authentic pizza in brooklyn

Crossing the Brooklyn Bridge into DUMBO, you'll discover Grimaldi's, an iconic pizza restaurant where the tantalizing scent of fresh tomatoes, basil, and melted cheese wafts through the historic cobblestone streets. This revered establishment has earned its place among the best pizza places in NYC, with its coal-fired brick oven pizzas that embody the spirit of New York City pizza.

  • Grimaldi's is famous for:
  • Its Brooklyn roots: Despite its fame among Manhattan NYC pizza connoisseurs, this joint remains true to its DUMBO origins.
  • Signature coal-fired oven: This is the heart of Grimaldi's, giving their pizzas that unique, smoky flavor.
  • The Queue: Being the best pizza in New York City means a line, but the freedom to savor a slice of Grimaldi's is worth the wait.

Artichoke Basille's: Chelsea Treat

artichoke basille s pizza delight

Nestled in the heart of Chelsea, you'll find Artichoke Basille's, a gem among Manhattan's pizza scene known for its unique, creamy artichoke pizza. From the first bite, you're catapulted into a world of rich, creamy sauce and perfectly baked crust.

This pizza place has carved out a niche in the midtown area, proudly serving what many consider the best pizza in Manhattan.

The artichoke pizza, their signature dish, is a twist on traditional New York-style pizza. It's the perfect blend of artichoke hearts, spinach, cream sauce, mozzarella, and pecorino romano cheese. It's this kind of innovation that sets Artichoke Basille's apart from the myriad of other pizza restaurants in the city.

Roberta's: Brooklyn's Best

gourmet pizza in brooklyn

If you find yourself in Brooklyn and you're keen on exploring its culinary delights, you absolutely can't miss Roberta's, a pizza joint that has rapidly risen to the top of the city's food scene with its wood-fired pies and an effortlessly cool vibe. This isn't just a pizza restaurant; it's an experience that embodies the spirit of Manhattan NYC.

Among the best pizza restaurants, Roberta's stands out with its:

  • Unconventional approach to traditional New York pizza.
  • Unique and exotic toppings that redefine your pizza experience.
  • Ambiance that resonates with the freedom-seeking, hip Brooklyn crowd.

Roberta's pizza isn't just about satisfying your taste buds, but also about challenging your culinary assumptions. It's an absolute must-visit for any pizza lover in the city.

Motorino Pizzeria: East Village Gem

authentic neapolitan pizza experience

While Roberta's might be challenging culinary norms in Brooklyn, over in the East Village, Motorino Pizzeria is crafting Neapolitan pies that have become a beloved fixture in the Manhattan pizza scene. This East Village gem is a beacon for pizza lovers, serving some of the best Neapolitan pizza in town.

The atmosphere is relaxed yet vibrant, reflecting the spirit of freedom that New Yorkers so cherish. It's not just a pizza spot, it's an experience.

You can see the mastery in their craftsmanship as the pizza dough is hand-stretched, topped with fresh ingredients, and sent into a blistering hot oven. Delectable, artisanal, and authentic, Motorino Pizzeria is undoubtedly one of the best pizza places in Manhattan, a must-visit for every pizza aficionado out there.

Kesté Pizza & Vino: Neapolitan Delight

authentic neapolitan pizza experience

Staking its claim in the heart of Greenwich Village, Kesté Pizza & Vino takes you on a culinary journey with its authentic Neapolitan pizzas, transforming a simple meal into an unforgettable experience.

When this Italian restaurant opened, it quickly became a favorite among Manhattan NYC pizza restaurants. The secret to their success? An authentic slice of Naples in every bite.

  • Authenticity: Kesté remains true to its Neapolitan roots, delivering a slice of Italy right to you.
  • Ingredients: Every ingredient is carefully selected, ensuring the highest quality.
  • Cooking Process: The traditional wood-fired oven gives their pizzas a unique, smoky flavor.

For freedom seekers, Kesté is the perfect escape to experience the authentic Italian culture in the midst of the bustling city.

Lucali: Carroll Gardens Hotspot

hip pizza joint in brooklyn

Venturing beyond the borders of Greenwich Village, you'll find another gem in the pizza landscape of Manhattan NYC, Lucali, nestled in the heart of Carroll Gardens.

This pizza parlor is a hotspot that radiates authenticity and freedom, serving up wood-fired, thin-crust pies. At Lucali, the emphasis is on simplicity and quality. Every bite of the whole pie reveals a perfect balance of flavors, from the sweet tomato sauce to the meltingly tender mozzarella. The crust, thin and beautifully charred, adds a smoky note to the symphony of tastes.

The dimly lit atmosphere and rustic decor of the restaurant further enhance the experience. It's no wonder that Lucali has become a must-go destination for pizza lovers in Carroll Gardens and beyond.

Serafina: Always Pasta & Pizza

italian cuisine at serafina

Just a stone's throw away from Times Square, you'll stumble upon Serafina: Always Pasta & Pizza, a bustling Italian eatery in Manhattan that serves up an enticing range of classic and inventive pizzas, perfectly capturing the vibrant culinary energy of the city. This sit-down restaurant is a testament to the best pizza restaurants in Manhattan NYC.

Serafina's pizza counter is a hub of activity. Offering a selection of New York style pizzas that are a perfect blend of thin, crispy crust, rich tangy sauce, and gooey mozzarella. Featuring a selection of unique toppings that can cater to the wildest of your pizza fantasies. A bustling locale where you can see your pizza being prepared right in front of you, adding to the overall dining experience.

Luzzo's: Authentic Italian

luzzo s true italian cuisine

If you're seeking a taste of authentic Italian pizza in the heart of Manhattan, then Luzzo's should be high on your list. Recognized as one of the best pizza restaurants, Luzzo's takes pride in their traditional Neapolitan pies. You can taste the distinct flavor in their dough, a recipe imported from Italy and perfected over generations.

As you step into Luzzo's, the welcoming, rustic ambiance transports you straight to the streets of Napoli. You're free to choose from a wide array of toppings, all sourced meticulously from Italy. The Margherita, their signature pizza, is a must-try. The crisp crust, rich tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella blend seamlessly, creating an unforgettable bite.

Luzzo's in Manhattan NYC offers you not just pizza, but a slice of Italy itself.

John's Pizzeria: Times Square

iconic pizzeria in times square

While Luzzo's gives you a slice of Italy, John's Pizzeria at Times Square offers a quintessential New York pizza experience that's hard to beat. This family owned and operated gem is renowned as one of the best pizza restaurants in Manhattan NYC.

  • John's Pizzeria: Times Square
  • New York-Style Slices: You'll love their iconic, crispy yet foldable slices. The thin, slightly charred crust is a hallmark of their wood-fired pizzas.
  • Neighborhood Pizza: Despite being in bustling Times Square, John's Pizzeria has retained its neighborhood charm. Its warm, inviting vibe will make you feel right at home.
  • Family Owned and Operated: Their commitment to quality and tradition is evident in every slice. This authentic touch sets them apart.

Experience the freedom to explore the variety of pizzas and feel the spirit of NYC in each bite.

Patsy's Pizzeria: East Harlem

authentic pizza in east harlem

Stepping into Patsy's Pizzeria in East Harlem, you're immediately enveloped by the tantalizing aroma of baking dough and melting cheese, a testament to the century-old tradition of crafting mouthwatering New York-style pizzas.

This pizza stalwart, open since 1933, has earned its spot among the best pizza restaurants in Manhattan NYC. The menu is straightforward, but the magic lies in the simplicity of their oven pizza, with its perfect balance of chewy crust, zesty tomato sauce, and stringy mozzarella. Each pie is a tangible reflection of East Harlem's rich culinary history.

As the oven roars, you can almost hear the whispers of the countless stories it has baked into every slice. Patsy's Pizzeria offers not just a pizza, but an experience – a delicious slice of freedom.

Bleecker Street Pizza: Greenwich Village

iconic pizza in greenwich village

Just as Patsy's Pizzeria serves as a historic culinary cornerstone in East Harlem, Bleecker Street Pizza in Greenwich Village stands as a beacon of gastronomic brilliance, showcasing the perfect blend of tradition and innovation in every bite. This West Village gem is a must-visit among the best pizza restaurants in Manhattan NYC.

Bleecker Street Pizza's uniqueness lies in:

  • Its traditional New York style thin-crust pizza that has a perfect crunch to it, a trademark of Greenwich Village pizzerias.
  • The vibrant, artistic culture of the West Village reflected in its diverse menu.
  • A freedom-loving atmosphere where you can enjoy an authentic slice of Manhattan NYC while immersing yourself in the local vibe.

Visit for a pizza experience that's a cut above the rest.

Rubirosa Ristorante: SoHo Favorite

italian cuisine in soho

Nestled in the heart of SoHo, you'll find Rubirosa Ristorante, a beloved pizza spot that's been serving up authentic Italian slices to Manhattan's most discerning pizza connoisseurs for years. This SoHo favorite stands out among the best pizza restaurants in Manhattan NYC.

Rubirosa's thin-crust pizzas are a testament to their commitment to quality. You'll be captivated by the perfect balance of crisp crust, fresh mozzarella, and flavorful toppings, each bite a symphony of textures and tastes. They've mastered the art of pizza, creating an experience that's both comforting and liberating.

The authenticity of Rubirosa Ristorante's pizza sends a clear message: freedom lies not in reinventing the wheel, but in perfecting the craft, and honoring tradition.

Joe's Pizza: West Village Classic

delicious pizza in west village

In the heart of the West Village, you'll discover Joe's Pizza, a classic Manhattan establishment renowned for its traditional New York-style slices that have been satisfying pizza lovers for decades. This Bleecker Street icon is best known for its thin-crust pies, cooked to perfection and served in generous slices.

Here's what you can expect:

  • The best slices in NYC, each one a testament to the art of pizza-making.
  • Crisp, thin crust that's never soggy or undercooked
  • Generously topped with fresh ingredients and just the right amount of cheese and sauce
  • A taste of true New York slice, a culinary symbol of freedom and diversity
  • A West Village ambiance that's as authentic as Joe's pizza itself

Visit Joe's and experience the magic of traditional New York pizza.

Prince Street Pizza: Nolita's Best

delicious pizza in nolita

While you're savoring the classic taste of Joe's Pizza in the West Village, don't forget to make a stop at Prince Street Pizza, another gem in the pizza landscape of Manhattan, particularly in the Nolita neighborhood.

It's one of the best pizza restaurants in Manhattan NYC, renowned for its distinct square slice. The crust, perfectly crispy on the outside yet fluffy inside, provides an ideal stage for the toppings. Your taste buds will cherish the harmony between the rich, tangy tomato sauce, the melt-in-your-mouth mozzarella, and whatever topping you choose.

The intensity of flavors is amplified by the freshness of ingredients. At Prince Street Pizza in Nolita, each slice is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to quality, making it a must-visit on your pizza exploration journey.

Conclusion

So, you've now explored the best pizza spots in Manhattan. From Lombardi's traditional pies in Little Italy to the unique flavors of Roberta's in Brooklyn. Whether you're digging into Grimaldi's classic slices or enjoying Artichoke Basille's Chelsea treats, you're experiencing the true taste of NYC.

Don't forget to visit Motorino Pizzeria, Bleecker Street Pizza, Rubirosa Ristorante, Joe's Pizza, and Prince Street Pizza. No matter where you end up, you'll surely be in for a delicious treat.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *